7.21.2012

review: how I flew United but kept landing in Howard Johnson


(this is a style blog, so i rarely, if ever, post on an unrelated topic. however, my recent flight nightmare of epic proportions warrants an exception.) 

a week and a half ago, i was due to fly out of Shanghai to Newark on a United Airlines flight. having flown this 13-hour jaunt many times before, i was looking forward to putting on my Bose headphones and dozing off to some in-flight movies. check baggage, get boarding pass, go through immigration and security check, kindle at the gate until boarding. piece of cake, right?

wrong.

this is what happened instead.

day 1: 
a few minutes before our scheduled departure time, the Chinese supervising gate agent abruptly announces that our flight had been cancelled. no apologetic tone, no explanations, no earlier warning so that people could call around or look for other flights departing out that day. we are told curtly to exit back out through immigration, retrieve our baggage, and wait in line at the check-in counter for instructions. 

at check-in, only to be told that due to the oversold flights, there were no other flight options with other airlines that day or the next. the vague explanation? "mechanical issues".

i and about 250 other passengers end up at a Howard Johnson in the middle of nowhere in the suburban expanse of Pudong. there's a mediocre buffet. i call United's US 1-800 number. an agent tells me they're swapping out a new plane and we'd be good to fly tomorrow. the hotel front desk tells us that we'd get word from the airline later in the evening.

radio silence.

day 2: 
morning, more radio silence.

around noon, finally the hotel notifies us that we're rescheduled to depart at 8pm.

at check-in, the Chinese United agents mill around looking lazy and gossippy. nothing happens for over an hour and a half.

around 6pm, they finally start. we are told that they haven't assigned us a gate yet because all the gates are full. i check my luggage. go through immigration. and then security. head to the gate. it all seems so déja-vu.

it is now 7:30pm, half an hour before our scheduled departure time of 8pm. people are pissed. no announcements. the incompetent counter agents are utterly disrespectful when asked by passengers for an update on the situation.

finally, a few middle-aged Chinese guys lose it. they start yelling, cursing, and demanding that the supervisor show up and make an official announcement for this unacceptable fiasco. the supervising agent finally shows up, tells everyone to wait another half hour for an update.

radio silence.

an hour later, the pilot gives the update: they're unable to fix the mechanical issue, so this flight is cancelled again. it is now way too late in the evening for anyone to try to get another flight out. the airport is pretty much shutting down. 

a small hell is breaking loose. a group of middle-aged and elderly Chinese passengers begin circulating a petition. another Chinese guy is soapboxing about how a third of us should defect to a hotel and try to force the airline's hand. 

at check-in, i somehow luck out and get a flight for the next day with another airline with a connection. everyone is exhausted, sweaty, and almost delirious on the shuttle bus ride back to the Howard Johnson.

by the time we get back to the hotel, it is almost midnight.

day 3:
i fly out in the AM without incident on another airline. the flight attendants are incredibly nice and attentive. the food is really good. 

alas, this doesn't last as my connecting flight is United. i spot three United flight attendants standing in the back, gossiping and just hanging out. instead of, you know, doing their job. 

i ask a flight attendant to help me find a place for my carry-on. no such luck, she just gives me a condenscending attitude. another girl sitting behind me and i end up helping each other with our carryons. 

as for the other people's day 3 who were still stuck on the original flight, it looks like hell really did break loose. see Good Morning America's report here.

in the week since, i have not heard a peep from United on remedying this mess. after several phone calls, i finally got my ticket refunded. no info as of yet on the rest of the travel compensation.

this is not wholly a case of blaming United for a mechanical problem. rather, it's quite damning proof that United utterly failed to handle the problem with timely, empathetic communication and customer service. 

i have tried calling several times, and have only gotten further runaround from atrociously long wait times (the record so far is 45 minutes...) and unintelligible agents working from some outsource farm. at this point, i am convinced that United and its so-called customer service phone lines truly occupy a large swath of the 8th circle of Dante's Inferno.

dear readers, i need your help. 

do any of you have suggestions or advice for any way to get speedy resolution from United? do you have any airline horror stories (United or otherwise) of your own? how did you end up resolving it? finally, does anyone have recommendations for good airlines/frequent flyer programs?

update 7/26: i got a packet in the mail with an apology letter and gift card from Customer Relations, and a reassurance that the rest of my travel compensation will be processed soon. we'll see how this plays out. fingers crossed... 

35 comments:

  1. Dear Lord,

    I hope you never wind up in United/Hell again.

    Years ago now, I flew United domestic--and it was HORRIBLE. I've refused ever since. Let them go bankrupt and let the worthless employees (but not the good ones, if there are any) remain unemployed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i am honestly shocked that they are still somehow in business after what seems to be a unanimous chorus of horror stories. ugh. and seriously, where do they find their flight attendants? they are the most hostile and unfriendly bunch i have ever encountered on ANY airline.

      Delete
  2. Sounds awful. I'm a 1k with united - you could try the 1k line, which I know is answered in Denver: 800-225-8900.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks Jennipher for the # - i'll try calling tomorrow...

      Delete
  3. Wow what a nightmare!! This is horrible. Do you have status with United? I fly them a lot but I have to say that it's hard to get (in my experience) anything from them without some kind of status. I might try pinging them on Twitter, which may be more effective.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yeah i think twitter is the way to go. it's a shame that most airlines operate on the Titanic model of service (or lack thereof).

      Delete
  4. I'm loving your blog (I've been a stealth reader for a while).

    I adored Continental and was a 2-decade faithful customer, flying between Houston, NYC, Seattle and Anchorage for years. Now that they are United, the on-board experience is lacking and their customer service is bad (I assume that is the United side of operations). Having recently had a near-nightmare in overseas travels (Lisbon to Austin, re-routed through Paris and Atlanta), I don't think there's anything you can do. Ours was a delayed luggage situation (5 days delayed getting luggage home after a flight cancellation and delayed flight and free overnight accommodations at the Paris Comfort Inn), and we were powerless. As much as I hate to be a victim and be passive, the only thing you can do is pack defensively and be prepared with your Bose headphone recharging unit. That and time-share a private jet, which is my ultimate ambition that will never come to fruition. Modern travel is de-humanizing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thanks Rebekah! always love to hear from my readers. do comment more often! :)

      i know - i was really looking forward to flying Continental actually, until the merger...you're definitely right that modern travel is dehumanizing. our standards have sunk SO LOW.

      Delete
  5. Wow, what a nightmare! I just flew United from YVR to LAX and back. Going there there were multiple delays leaving (about 2 hours total- nothing compared to your ordeal!), and the interior of the plane was very old, basic and cramped. Flying back was much better, as it was operated by Air Canada. Nicer plane, staff, actual in flight entertainment. And I usually swear off Air Canada, as every flight I've flown with them they've lost my bag! I guess there really IS worse airlines!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. you know, i am puzzled as to why the US and perhaps Canadian airlines are SO GODAWFUL. even the Chinese domestic airlines i've flown with at least have staff that are trying to do their job properly. why are our airlines so bad??

      Delete
  6. I highly recommend Cathay Pacific; I've traveled to and from Asia with them a dozen times, and have always had a great experience. Their frequent flyer program is also great, and if you get a chance to fly with them first/business class, it's an amazing experience.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with AJ I highly recommend Cathay Pacific to and from Asia. There first/business class is AMAZING. The flight times are very convenient when it comes to reducing jet lag and the service is top notch. I also love Singapore air.

    Flying United internationally is asking for trouble. I refuse to fly with them even on business. I'm sorry to hear this. It sounds miserable.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. AJ & Lindsay - thanks for your recs! i'm hoping that someday soon i'll be able to enjoy first or biz class on Cathay or Singapore Air :) i'll consider that a career milestone!

      Delete
  8. My top recommendation would be Emirates, which is just fantastic. I second Lindsay on Singapore airlines and Cathay pacific. It will be a while before I fly any US airline - Asian/Gulf airlines do a much better job with food and service, even in economy.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I've avoided flying United for the past 10 years because of one bad experience (lazy, hostile staff) and numerous horror stories from friends. Sadly, your story does not surprise me. Also sadly, I'm flying them to Australia in a few months (not my choice).

    How about filing a formal complaint to the FAA? If United won't listen to you, they might listen to them. This also formally documents their shitty service.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yep. the lazy hostile staff bit sounds exactly right from pretty much all of my experiences with United flights.

      the FAA sounds like a good idea. i just can't believe that even with such a horrendous, national headline-making flight, they have offered NOTHING to the passengers and instead are making people do all the work to even get a modicum of acknowledgement for this fiasco.

      Delete
  10. This is terrible! My return flight from Frankfurt was oversold but Lufthansa was reasonably on the ball about alternate arrangements and compensation, and since I wasn't in a big hurry to get home I have no major complaints about the whole affair. Yours, on the other hand, would put me off flying United forever.

    I've never flown on any US carriers unfortunately, but my friend is always telling how awesome the Delta frequent flyer programme is for earning miles.

    Lufthansa and Cathay Pacific always have good service, Emirates has unbeatable inflight entertainment (they give the entire season of a TV show, not just a few episodes on long haul flights) but hit and miss service, Singapore Airlines is all-round good but often pricey. I stick to Lufthansa and Singapore Airlines because I can earn miles on my frequent flyer programme from both of them, and since Lufthansa upgraded their fleet their flights have become infinitely more pleasant. I also like Cathay because they always have good flight times and prices but they get snapped up so fast. Thai Airways has an older fleet but their service is great.

    Recently a group of tourists in Singapore refused to disembark from their flight until they got a personal apology from the airline for their 20 hour delay - I suppose it's too late for you try that haha. I think bugging them on their social media outlets like Facebook and Twitter can be quite effective.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yeah i'd advise you to avoid all US carriers at all costs. i've heard wonderful things about all the other airlines you mention. especially Cathay and Singapore Airlines, which get rave reviews from everyone.

      i love that the tourists in Singapore have much higher standards and did that as a protest - just goes to show that they are NOT used to the shit experiences US carrier passengers encounter all too often.

      Delete
  11. I had a similar experience in 2007 with Alaskan, getting stuck in the Juneau airport for 30 hours because of 3 consecutive planes that flew in with some mechanical issue. I was flying Alaskan weekly for a few years, and they almost always were late with our luggage on every flight (I took to never checking luggage after awhile). Free/reduced fare tickets from them as a result were a mixed blessing, as I knew they would result in a similar experience the next time. A lot of people must have complained, however, as they now have a "20 minutes or less" guarantee for checked luggage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. you know, United had another multi-day flight delay nightmare on a flight from SF to SH earlier this year. something very similar to your story happened, all because of broken toilets. that made the news too. oy...

      Delete
  12. o my god!! i had the same experience in kenya with british airways but it lasted 5 days!!!! when i finally made it to london they comped us a pretty nice hotel room and a 15 pound voucher for airport goodies. that was it. if i could go back in time, i'd call the airline multiple times and write a letter. i haven't flown BA since. i do love love virgin airlines and lufthansa/KLM. never had any issues with them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i need to try out Virgin Airlines after all the rave reviews i've heard about them. i can't believe you had a 5-day delay. did it make the news??

      Delete
  13. United sucks. Period. I had an awful experience with them 2 months ago: drunk passengers making racist and sexist jokes/remarks and a flight crew that JOINED IN and kept serving them drinks rather than try to contain the situation. Oh, and we were delayed as well as trapped on the plan for 45 minutes after arrival because of a mechanical issue. I wrote United's "customer service" address and received a response over a month later. They apologized and gave me 3000 bonus miles, which of course are useless to me because I refuse to every fly with them again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. omg - that sounds horrendous! i never had favorable impressions of the United flight attendants, but your story and my own experience has confirmed that they must recruit from the delinquents and fired staff from all the other airlines.

      Delete
  14. Wow that's so insane! I've only flown United on domestic flights and have actually never experienced delays or hostile staff. Your experience will make me avoid United for any international flights however. I can't believe they weren't more open with information; I think everyone understands that mechanical problems happen, but it's really how the airline responds to these problems that distinguishes good and bad service.

    I second everyone's recommendations for Cathay Pacific on Asia flights though, my experience with them was absolutely fantastic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. exactly. it was so condescending how they kept witholding ANY info until past the last minute. and their Shanghai airport United staff are beyond unprofessional.

      Delete
  15. OK, I'll fess up. That was me who staged the delays. I contacted United and paid them to put on the show. it was all an act to get you to stay in Shanghai. but it didnt work obviously. I thought that if at least 2 flights got cancelled you'd see it as a sign and get back into a Taxi and head back into town. damnit!-s

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ha! i have to say, the thought did occur to me at some point after the cancelled my flight the 2nd night...

      Delete
  16. I haven't flown anything but Delta for years. I've flown United and American both once, and swore never again. I had a four hour delay in San Francisco with United (which is nothing compared to your ordeal) and a day long battle with American. People may say what they want about Delta, but they've really tried to clean up their image as of late. They have a very responsive Twitter account, which you can tweet at for any mishaps you have on their flight.

    I also love that they're paired with some really great international airlines - I only fly Korean Air when I go to Asia, which is beneficial for me as I can always use a layover in Seoul to see family before I go anywhere. I don't think they service any direct flights to China (but don't quote me on it), but if you don't mind a brief sojourn to the land of the morning calm (so lame, I know), I highly recommend flying Korean Air. I've never once had an issue with me. The only time I was delayed was two years ago when Seoul was in an insane fog situation, but they kept all the passengers updated on the status of the flight regularly and the promised 30 min. delay ended up being only 10 min. Fantastic.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hmm, a few friends have recommended Delta as well. i suppose they're at least making an effort to remedy their company. United seems to be run by a gang of people who just. don't. care.

      Delete
  17. I don't know about getting a response from them, but I did send a link to your article to my friend Thomas Peele, author of award-winning bestseller, Killing the Messenger.
    Peel is also an investigative reporter who has been bitching about United on FB for the past month. xoxo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ah, i really appreciate that, thank you Kristi! i'd be curious what your friend Thomas experienced with United as well!

      Delete
  18. Around the same time as your travel fiasco, I noticed several FB friends also complaining about canceled flights and lost/damaged luggage on United. It's either a strange coincidence or a sign that the airline is really going downhill. I usually have no airline loyalty and just fly whatever carrier is offering the cheapest rate, but from now on, I think I'm going to avoid flying United.

    I really hope United sorts this whole thing out for you.

    ReplyDelete
  19. This is truly horrific. I have never experienced (fingers crossed) anything to this extent. The compensation is the minimum they should do for those of you who were treated no better than animals. I suggest they offer a free flight. The thing is most airlines are losing money and the negative feedback isn't doing them any good.

    ReplyDelete

feel free to join in on the style conversation. thoughtful comments are most appreciated. :) FYI, comment moderation is on, so it may take a little while before your comment appears.